Welcome to Camp Should-A-Been!
What would the American Idol season outcomes have been if we viewers had voted solely on performance? A lot different than they actually turned out, that's for sure. Here at WhatNotToSing.com's legendary Camp Should-A-Been, we turn this hypothetical fantasy into...uh, real fantasy, disguised as reality. Plus we throw in a few laughs along the way.
Check back throughout the Summer of 2008 as we replay every episode of every season, with cold, objective, and thoroughly unsentimental voting based on WNTS.com's exclusive Web Approval Ratings. We'll try to put a new episode result online every night.
A compete introduction to Camp Should-A-Been and the rules of the competition can be found in our editorial library. Read it before you check out the results, or else the goings-on might not make much sense.
Results
- Season One is complete.
- Season Two is complete.
- Season Three is complete.
- Season Four is underway!
- Season Five
- Season Six
- Season Seven
-- The staff of WNTS.com