WhatNotToSing.com is the Internet's most comprehensive public reference site on American Idol, from Season One to the present. You'll find information in our database on every episode, every contestant, every song, and every performance, from the earliest semifinals through the season finales. Everything is cross-referenced and cross-linked, so you can easily find exactly what you're looking for.
In addition, every performance is rated on a scale of 0 to 100 (or from one star to five stars if you prefer), based on an extensive sampling of reviews and opinions from across the Web. We collect data after every episode from online news outlets, professional music critics, blogs, forums, boards, chat rooms, and polls. Then we crunch the numbers to produce a consensus rating of each performance – 50 is average, 90 or above is very strong (fewer than one performance in thirty scores that high), and anything under 10 is...well, you know.
Beginning in AI7, we'll have "overnight" ratings posted on our home page after every performance episode, with "final" ratings following a few days later. We'll also check in every week with editorials and analysis on the current season and interesting discussions of historical trends.
For more information, check out the links below or just browse the site and enjoy.