Google


Anchor Performances

A common complaint among American Idol fans is that the producers often save the most desirable performance slot of the evening – the final one – for their favored contestants. Some detractors have gone so far as to dub it "The Pimp Spot," perhaps in reaction to the shenanigans of Season Two when Clay Aiken and Ruben Studdard sang last a whopping nine times combined, including each of the final seven episodes. If Kimberley Locke had dragged Simon Fuller onto the stage and slapped him silly on national TV, would any jury have convicted her?

Thankfully, AI has been a bit more reasonable in recent years about sharing the spotlight. For instance, ten different contestants had a turn in the anchor spot in Season Six, including much-maligned Sanjaya Malakar who came through admirably with his highest-rated performance. And to be fair to the producers, they have a legitimate business interest in saving the best for last. A great anchor performance can help whitewash 55 minutes of lackluster singing, sends the audience off on a good note, and helps kick-starts the voting. "Leave 'em laughing when you go" was a basic tenet of show business long before Judy Collins sang those words.

Whatever the producers' motiviations, the Pimp Spot usually lives up to the hype: An average approval rating of 64.8, 63 five-star performances (including 14 rating out at 90 or higher), and most significantly, an elimination rate close to zero. Through the first seven seasons, just four finalists — 4! — have been knocked out of the competition from the anchor slot: Aiken in the AI2 Finale, Melinda Doolittle in AI6's Final Three, David Archuleta in the AI7 finale, and...can you guess the fourth? Page through the list below for the unlikely answer (or, if you don't feel like searching, just hover your pointer here.)

[back to top] Anchor Performances

Click on a column header to sort by that column.
# Episode / Theme Slot Performance Approval Rating σ Result
1
Open
10/10
Still In Love0003Still In Love
49
 
23 5Wild Card
2
Open
10/10
Ribbon In The Sky0003Ribbon In The Sky
61
 
17 2Safe
3
Open
10/10
At Last0003At Last
60
 
21 2Safe
4
Open
5/5
As We Lay0003As We Lay
43
 
23 7Eliminated
5
Motown
10/10
Aint No Mountain High Enough0003Ain't No Mountain High Enough
48
 
16 2Safe
6
1960s
8/8
You Really Got Me0003You Really Got Me
10
 
15 4Bottom Group
7
1970s
7/7
If I Were Your Woman0003If I Were Your Woman
76
 
12 2Safe
8
Big Band
6/6
Stuff Like That There0003Stuff Like That There
95
 
11 2Safe
9
Burt Bacharach Love Songs
5/5
Always Something There To Remind Me0003(There's) Always Something There To Remind Me
15
 
18 4Bottom Group
10
1980s & 1990s
8/8
PYT Pretty Young Thing0003P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing)
17
 
15 2Safe
11
Idol's Choice / Judge's Choice
6/6
Without You0003Without You
82
 
17 2Safe
12
Finale
6/6
Before Your Love0003Before Your Love
74
 
20 2Safe
13
Open
8/8
Son Of A Preacher Man0003Son Of A Preacher Man
70
 
16 2Safe
14
Open
8/8
I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Who Loves Me)0003I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Who Loves Me)
19
 
20 7Eliminated
15
Open
8/8
Unchained Melody0003Unchained Melody
32
 
23 7Eliminated
16
Open
8/8
Foolish Heart0003Foolish Heart
64
 
22 2Safe
17
Open
9/9
Lets Stay Together0003Let's Stay Together
80
 
12 3Judges' Choice
18
Motown
12/12
Baby I Need Your Loving0003Baby I Need Your Loving
76
 
16 2Safe
19
Movie Hits
11/11
Home 10003Home
67
 
12 2Safe
20
Country Rock
10/10
Someone Elses Star0003Someone Else's Star
56
 
22 2Safe
21
Disco
8/8
Celebration0003Celebration
9
 
10 2Safe
22
Billboard #1 Hits
8/8
Kiss And Say Goodbye0003Kiss And Say Goodbye
87
 
17 2Safe
23
Billy Joel
7/7
Tell Her About It0003Tell Her About It
73
 
16 2Safe
24
Diane Warren Songs
6/6
Music Of My Heart0003Music Of My Heart
59
 
17 2Safe
25
1960s / Neil Sedaka
10/10
Solitaire0003Solitaire
92
 
14 2Safe
WhatNotToSing.com copyright © 2007-2014, The WNTS Team.  All rights reserved.  Use of this website implies that you accept our Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy.  American Idol is a registered trademark of 19 TV Ltd.  We are not affiliated in any way with American Idol, Fox Television, FremantleMedia North America, or any of their parent or subsidiary companies.